Opinion: A Fat Bike Is the Best One-Bike Quiver on a Budget

Teton Canyon, Wyoming
Teton Canyon, Wyoming

Editor’s Note: When looking to get more serious about mountain biking, Aaron chose to buy a fat bike as his one-quiver bike–and the decision has been working out great for him! While Aaron Couch is a regular contributor to Singletracks.com, any opinions expressed in this article are his alone and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Singletracks.com.

You’re looking to upgrade your mountain bike, but you’re on a tight budget. That’s no surprise, as most of us are. Being on a tight budget, you want your money to go far. You need one bike with high-quality components, capable of handling a variety of terrain: dirt, rocks, sand, snow. Being on a budget means you can’t afford a new bike, or don’t want to. Buying a used suspension bike creates another issue: repairs and increased maintenance, meaning more time in the shop and less time on the trails.

Trek - snow 5
Early season in Grand Targhee Resort

These were the issues I faced when upgrading from my rigid Trek 820 Mountain Track. I needed suspension, better brakes, a larger frame for a better fit, access to better components, wider handlebars… need I go on? My Trek got me into mountain biking and had been all over from Kentucky to Kansas to Utah to Idaho and beyond.

trek - splash
Riding the Trek 820 on Crystal Springs Trail, Pocatello, Idaho

Omniterra: The word means “all earth.” That’s what a fat bike is truly capable of. Fat tires, though not a replacement for suspension, still offer more grip and damping than a rigid 29” or 27.5” wheelset. Fat tires also enable year-round riding without limitations.

Surly - splash
Red Creek Loop / Big Hole Mountains, Idaho

What about a plus tire bike?

I seriously considered this. I could ride most snow, right? It would have less rolling resistance than a fat tire and still be an upgrade. I had my eye on the Surly Krampus and Salsa Deadwood. But then the local bike shop pointed something out to me: You can install plus-size wheels on a fat bike frame, but you can’t put fat tires on a plus-sized frame. Simple as that, and this is what sold me.

There isn’t much difference between a plus tire bike and a fat bike, other than the size of the front fork and rear stays. Fat bikes offer the most versatility and best bang for the buck. Additionally, a plus-tire is not legal and doesn’t comply with the etiquette on groomed snow singletrack, where a tire width of 3.8” or wider is required.

The Bike of Choice

Surly - snow 1
Surly Pugsley Ops in its natural habitat / Cache Creek, Jackson, Wyoming

I found a used, steel-frame Surly Pugsley Ops that included aftermarket carbon fiber handlebars and fork, and hydraulic brakes. The bike was set up tubeless with Rolling Darryl rims and 45nrth Husker Du tires. There were a bunch of other accessories included as well. I scored this for $700 – an awesome price! Knowing the seller helped, but even at $1000 this would have been a great deal.

As a Trail Bike: Dirt, Rocks, Sand

Surly - desert
Navajo Rocks Loop / Moab, Utah. Photo: Megan Davin
Surly - desert 3
Navajo Rocks Loop / Moab, Utah. Photo: Megan Davin

Dropping down steep slickrock, there are often large sandy patches. Any traditional tire width would make the landing pretty squirrelly. With a fat tire, you get the grip you need on the slickrock and control you need in the sand. Taking wide corners on loose soil is no problem. When descending down rocky, rooty, and rutted out trails, the 3.8 Surly Nate tires handle it all.

Surly - dirt 5
Horseshoe Canyon / Big Hole Mountains, Idaho

On Downhill, Drops and Jumps

“I’ve never thought of jumping a fat bike before,” was one of the reactions I got this fall when playing around at the local pump track and bike park. I’m not a “downhiller,” but can a rigid fat bike can handle 3-foot drops, gap jumps, and rock gardens? Absolutely. Go to YouTube and check out what athletes are doing on rigid fat bikes – it’s impressive.

Surly - double black 1
Hiline Trail / Sedona, Arizona

While Bikepacking and Cycling Long Distances

Riding a fat bike long distances certainly is more difficult than a cyclocross bike, but very possible. This past September (2016), I finished JayP’s 120-mile Gravel Pursuit on my fat bike.

I recently bikepacked the full 155-mile Maah Daah Hey trail, which is 95% singletrack, in 4 days. I’ve gone on several 50 to 60-mile day rides, as well as bikepacking trips with 70+ mile back-to-back days.

Surly - bikepacking - steve
Caribou-Targhee National Forest, Idaho. Rider: Steve Griffin
Joe - bikepacking MDH
Maah Daah Hey Trail / North Dakota Badlands. Rider: Joe Stiller

You could say the fat bike is the perfect bikepacking rig. Regardless of the conditions, you don’t have to carry your bike through roads and trails that might be impassable for most bikes.

Joe - bikepacking sand 2
Sandbar along the Missouri River / South Dakota. Rider: Joe Stiller

During Questionable Trail Conditions

In my experience, fat tires are capable of passing through more variable conditions without damaging the trail. I’ve witnessed mountain bikers on 2.25 to 2.75-inch tires making ruts, while I roll right through the greasy spots, only leaving dimples from the tread. The fat bike is the perfect shoulder season companion.

Surly - badlands snow
Toadstool Geologic Park / Nebraska. Photo: Ridge Krisher
Surly - shoulder season 1
Red Canyon Rim Trail of Flaming Gorge / Utah (April 2016)

Of course, fat tires don’t give you a free pass – you still have to use common sense. However, when going over soft sections of trail, it’s unlikely you’ll do damage. Without a doubt, fat tires have much less impact than traditional mountain bike tires.

Snow Riding

Surly - snow 4
Sheep Bridge Trail / Teton Canyon, Wyoming. Photo: Tom Clayson

Obviously, this goes without saying that a fat bike is capable of such. When considering purchasing a fat bike, keep in mind what and where you will be riding. I would recommend you look at frames that support up to 5”-wide tires. You won’t use them in summer, but you’ll be glad you have the option when winter comes. That said, 3.8” tires will get you through most snow conditions. Check out our comprehensive guide to fat bike tires.

Surly - wheelie
Jolly Green Giant Trail / Grand Targhee Resort, Wyoming. Photo: Nan Pugh


Having a bike you can take anywhere and ask questions later is one less burden off your shoulders. Many of my trips lead to a a variety of locations and weather. Sometimes it rains or snows. Having a fat bike allows me to leave the uncertainty at the trailhead and go ride whatever my heart desires.

Surly - desert 1
Navajo Rocks Trail / Moab, Utah. Photo: Megan Davin

For the money, high-quality components and the option to ride year-round on all terrain, a fat bike is the true one-size-fits-all. It turns out you can have a high quality, inexpensive bike to tackle everything.