Red Hill stays pedal-only in BLM’s proposal to open Colorado River Valley trails to Class 1 e-bikes

The BLM proposes opening 118 miles of Colorado River Valley trails to Class 1 e-bikes, while Red Hill would remain pedal-only under the preferred option.
A person riding a mountain bike on a narrow dirt trail surrounded by trees and rocky terrain. Sunlight filters through the foliage, creating dappled shadows on the path. Red Hill mountain bike trail.
Red Hill. File photo: John Fisch

Red Hill, just north of Carbondale, sees more than 75,000 trail users a year, according to trail counter data collected by the Red Hill Council and cited by the Bureau of Land Management. Under the BLM’s proposed plan to open many Colorado River Valley trails to Class 1 e-bikes, the popular trail system would stay pedal-only.

The BLM’s Colorado River Valley Field Office released a draft environmental assessment on November 13 that narrows the proposal we reported on in February. Back then, the field office was considering e-bikes on all of its designated mountain bike trails. Now the agency’s proposed action would open 118 additional miles, while a second alternative would open 187 miles. A third option would leave things as they are, with the Grand Hogback system north of Rifle remaining the only BLM mountain bike trail network in the area where e-bikes are allowed.

The Crown, Eagle, and New Castle trails are in

The proposed action includes trails at The Crown near Carbondale (46 miles) and the Hardscrabble-East Eagle trails (38 miles), plus Third Gulch, Pipeline, Bailey, Riddle, and Boneyard, which sit just outside that area’s boundary but share its trailheads (4 miles). The New Castle trails (23 miles) and the Lorax Trail in the Thompson Creek area west of Carbondale (7 miles) round out the list.

That means Eagle favorites like World’s Greatest, Pool and Ice Rink, and Dirt Surfer 2.0 — which lie inside the Hardscrabble-East Eagle area — would be open to Class 1 e-bikes if the BLM goes with its proposed option.

Why Red Hill didn’t make the cut

Red Hill and the neighboring Sutey Ranch are managed as “OHV Closed” areas, meaning no motorized use is allowed on any route, unlike the other trail systems in the proposal. “The BLM specifically wants to consider an alternative where the Red Hill SRMA is not managed the same as the other SRMAs and ERMAs for e-bikes,” the draft EA says. During scoping, Pitkin County and Carbondale’s Bike, Pedestrian, & Trails Commission both sent letters opposing e-bikes at Red Hill, citing trail maintenance problems and user conflicts that come with heavy use.

“Public feedback played an important role in shaping the alternatives we’re now evaluating,” said Colorado River Valley Field Manager Lisa Dawson in a press release.

Red Hill’s roughly 21 miles are included in the broader 187-mile alternative, along with about 49 miles of trails outside the field office’s recreation areas, including Catamount Creek, East Glenwood Canyon, Fisher Creek, and Sheep Creek. According to the BLM, those outlying routes are mostly old two-track that see little use outside of fall hunting season. The agency says this “demonstrates a low public demand for e-bike use on mechanized trails that are not purpose-built for mountain biking.”

The BLM notes it can select one alternative or blend them, so individual trail systems could still move in or out of the final decision.

“Every trail system is different, and what works in one area may not work in another,” said BLM Colorado Outdoor Recreation Planner Alan Czepinski. “Comments about specific trails, user experiences and conditions on the ground are especially helpful as we evaluate where expanded access may be appropriate.”

Crossing onto town and county trails could get tricky

Many of these trail networks extend onto adjacent town and county land, including Pitkin County Open Space at the Crown and Town of Eagle and Eagle County open space at Hardscrabble-East Eagle. The draft EA says none of these adjoining land managers currently officially allow Class 1 e-bikes on their trails, though the BLM’s February scoping document listed Town of New Castle trails among neighboring lands where e-bikes are allowed. The towns of Eagle and New Castle sent letters supporting Class 1 e-bikes, and the BLM says it would strive to keep its rules consistent with neighboring land managers where trails cross jurisdictions.

New rules would come with access

Wherever e-bikes are allowed, the BLM says flow trails would become downhill-only, with directional signs at each end, and trailheads would get e-bike information. Existing winter wildlife closures, typically December 1 through April 15, would still apply. Three trails that connect to Forest Service land are off the table under any alternative: Scout, Arbaney Kittle, and the lower portion of Mansfield Ditch.

The BLM dismissed several other ideas, including allowing Class 2 and 3 e-bikes, requiring an e-bike permit, and starting with a limited pilot program. As far as pilot programs go, the agency says Grand Hogback has already served that purpose.

The public can comment on the draft EA through December 14 using the “Participate Now” button on the project page.

Keep up with the latest mountain bike news by adding Singletracks as a preferred source on Google.