I agree with the comment to “not over-think it”. Last year I spent months researching brands, components, builds, reviews, etc. I had a list of 5 bikes, demo’d them but couldn’t decide because they were all very similar with slightly different feels but none of them really stood out. The LBS suggested I demo the Ibis Ripley LS which wasn’t on my list, so I took it out and within 5 minutes I knew what bike I was getting…I didn’t want the ride to end. Everything was similar but the Ripley fit me perfectly and there was no question then and no regrets now. I’ve made the mistake of buying without demoing and those bikes typically haven’t lasted. Demo a variety on a trail you typically ride and one will stand out.
In the category of bike you are looking at, give a look to the Ibis Ripmo. I hear it’s is awesome on the descent and climbs like a smaller travel trail bike.