| Shop | City | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Fat Tire Cycle | Buckhannon |  |
| Pike Street Bikes | Shinnston | |
| Pathfinder | Morgantown | |
| Wamsley Cycles | Morgantown | |
| The True Wheel | Bluefield | |
| Charleston Bicycles Center | Charleston | |
| Blackwater Bikes | Davis |  |
| Arrowhead Bike Farm | Fayetteville | |
| Dirt Bean Bike Shop and Cafe | Marlinton |  |
| Ridersville Cycles | Berkeley Springs | |
| Eastern Panhandle Bicycle Company | Martinsburg | |
| Wheelbilly Bikes | Hurricane | |
| Pete's Bike Shop | Nitro | |
| John's Cyclery | St. Albans | |
| New River Bikes | Fayetteville | |
| Marathon Bikes | Fayetteville | |
| Valley Sports | Lewisburg | |
| Free Spirit Adventures & Bike Sales | Lewisburg | |