| Shop | City | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Hyland Cyclery | Salt Lake City |    |
| Idaho Mountain Touring | Boise | |
| Idaho Mountain Trading | Idaho Falls | |
| Ikon Cycles | Sacramento | |
| ILLINOIS CYCLE & FITNESS | Peoria | |
| In Competition Sports | Green Bay | |
| In gear | Lebanon | |
| Incycle | Pasadena | |
| Incycle | San Dimas | |
| Incycle Bicycles | Rancho Cucamonga | |
| Indian Cycle Fitness and Outdoor | Ridgeland | |
| Indian Cycle Fitness and Outdoor | Ridgeland | |
| Indian Valley Bikeworks | Harleysville | |
| Indiana Schwinn Cycling & Fitness Center | Indiana | |
| Infinity Bike Shop | Melbourne | |
| InMotion Bicycle Shop | Hamilton | |
| Internaional Pro | Bellbrook | |
| International Bicycle Center | Allston | |
| International Bicycle Center | Newton Highlands | |
| Intown Bicycles | Atlanta | |
| Iowa City Scheels | Coralville | |
| iRide | Stowe | |
| iRide Cycles | Huntersville | |
| Ironclad Bicycles | Prescott | |
| Islands Bicycles | Savannah | |